Published November 7, 2026
Zillow Gone Wild
I know what you're thinking -
Of course the real estate agent is going to write a hit piece on Zillow, they're trying to take his job.
That's not what this is. While I do take issue with parts of their model, I am not a Luddite when it comes to real estate technology (definition of a Luddite --> HERE). Zillow, Realtor.com, Homes.com, and all the others provide valuable information to the consumer and have done a lot to remove the gatekeeping aspect of real estate which I believe is a net positive for humanity.
Today's Hot Take is NOT going to to be a hit piece on Zillow. It serves to make you aware of a massive lawsuit that I have NOT seen reported much in the news. A lawsuit that concluded with the announcement of a $212 million payout to its investors and one that challenges our reliance on technology companies to make big, hairy, important decisions.
The Rub
Zillow's lawsuit is not about the Zestimate misleading consumers. The lawsuit actually stemmed from their home-flipping business. The model began with Zillow Offers. In my experience, these were typically below market offers that provided a quick close and flexible move-out options. Once Zillow took title to the home, they would rehab it (flip), and put it back on the market to make a profit. Easy right? They started in 2018 and then things really got spicy during COVID when the market took off.
The challenge is that margins were thin. Zillow took ownership of all those homes so they stayed on the balance sheet which meant they were susceptible to changes in home price, holding costs, and repair expenses on a very, very large scale. Do you see the problem?
What about the Zestimate?
The irony is that a company that built a reputation around reliable data, namely reliable home valuations, failed at a business model that relied on that very same data and those very same valuations. They were so confident in their data-driven approach, they developed an entirely new department devoted to buying up residential real estate to the tune of thousands of homes and then discovered that the nuances and complexities of residential real estate are much harder to predict than they anticipated.
Right now, Zillow is worth a little over $7 billion so let's not pull out the box of tissues yet.
I'm sure they had some very smart people who were paid a lot of money evaluating those deals and to say that inaccurate Zestimates led to its downfall would be an unfair generalization of the situation. The investors' attorneys alleged that executives made exaggerated statements or omitted material information regarding the volume at which they were purchasing homes, how reliably their models were pricing those homes, and how efficient their operations were.
What does this mean for you?
You don't read the Hot Take to learn about real estate technology companies. You come here to learn about what's happening in the Triangle. You want to know about how the market is doing here and what home prices are up to.
I get it.
I've been a real estate agent for nearly a decade. I represented a buyer who purchased a home that was owned by Zillow. I was on the ground during COVID. And I go on listing appointments every single week. I know the power of the Zestimate. It's sexy. It's easy to read. It's right there on your phone. It's confident and you can't resist the way it looks at you. Just click it.
But here's the thing. By Zillow's own admission, they claim the median error rate for off-market homes is 7.2%. If you're listing a $500k house the Zestimate could be $464,000 or it could be $536,000. Which is it? The people want to know. Or more accurately, YOU want to know.
When I go on a listing appointment, I always check the Zestimate because I know that's what my clients are looking at. The thing to remember is that there are two ways to consider the value of your home. There is the appraised value, and the value the market will bear. To be a licensed residential real estate appraiser in NC, you need over 1000 hours in the field. It's a lot of work. There's math involved. But they don't sell houses. They don't work with buyers every day. They can't quantify the slope in the backyard. They can't quantify the foundation crack that's not a big deal but looks like a big deal. There's no metric for an ugly carpet or funky smell. They can take those things into account and make an adjustment on an appraisal that amounts to a very real number. But they can't put a price on how buyers feel about it.
Same for the Zestimate.
That's where your real estate agent comes in
I can't count how many times I have listed a home and it was wildly different from the Zestimate only to wake up the next morning and see the Zestimate moved to exactly where we priced. I have a home on the market right now that was off by over $200k when I first listed it. My throat dropped into my belly because I know that buyers will notice the discrepancy. The next day, the Zestimate rose close to our list price. It happens all of the time.
I am by no means a data scientist, or a computer engineer, or a vibe coder, or an algorithm guy. I know what an algorithm is in theory but I don't think I really know what it IS.
What I do know is that the real estate market is dynamic. We are using yesterday's closings (which went under contract 30-60+ days prior) to predict tomorrow's prices.
That's what makes pricing so challenging.
I'm not suggesting that real estate agents know everything or are market wizards. Our own evaluations can be off as well. But I know that buyers place a premium on the flatness of a backyard. I know that it didn't matter a few years ago, but it does now. I know that buyers have very little tolerance to make improvements right now. I know that overpricing a home can be far more costly than it seems. I know that the number that matters most for sellers is not what the bank says it's worth, or the Zestimate. It's what a buyer is willing to pay. And if you reallllly want to sell your house, isn't that the only thing that matters?
Be smart. Be safe. Be content. Have a wonderful find,
Cory
p.s. As I was writing this, colorful leaves were drifting by the window giving major fall vibes. I assume at some point it will get cold out so in preparation, here's a list of my top 5 homes with amazing fireplaces.
